|Read time: 8 minutes||Written by: Corey Nelson|
Sometimes in the world of fitness and nutrition, scientific ideas once considered valid fade into obscurity. For example, the outdated claims that eggs cause heart attacks, or that low-fat, high-carb diets are superior for losing weight.
Far more often, “bro-science” that sounds legit spreads like wildfire with zero credible research to support it. Like concerns that creatine harms your kidneys, or that you can only absorb a limited amount of protein per meal.
But occasionally, ideas that sound like bro-science turn out to be effective. And sometimes, they’re even supported by scientific evidence.
The topic of this article, “metabolic confusion,” is the perfect example of a concept that seems kooky but deserves a closer look.
In this article, we’ll go over what people mean by metabolic confusion, whether it truly works, and how to understand and take advantage of the underlying truths — plus practical examples you can use today to lose weight, gain muscle, and transform your body.
The metabolic confusion diet, sometimes called calorie cycling or calorie shifting, is based on a principle called metabolic confusion.
In a nutshell, people who follow the metabolic confusion diet change up their calories, and often other macronutrients, in an attempt to “confuse” their metabolism and speed up the fat loss process.
As some advocates of the diet say, “you have to confuse it to lose it.”
First of all, we’ve got to be brutally honest here. The term “metabolic confusion” is entirely made up and unscientific.
Your body knows exactly what to do with calories and macronutrients, and there’s no real way to “confuse” it.
But that doesn’t answer the question of whether dietary practices like calorie cycling and carb cycling work.
Firstly, for plenty of people, cycling calories and macros is confusing and unnecessary.
So if you’re a beginner and your goal is to lose fat or build muscle, don’t obsess over these lesser details. Instead, focus on the basics — like showing up for workouts and eating a caloric surplus or caloric deficit as needed for your goals.
However, the surprising answer is that despite the silly name, metabolic confusion can still work.
Keep reading to learn more about the scientific principles that explain why calorie cycling and carb cycling diets can be highly effective for transforming your body.
Anecdotally, calorie cycling and carb cycling work exceptionally well. It’s a practice that works for people of all experience levels, including professional athletes, figure competitors, and bodybuilders.
But instead of anecdotes, let’s take a look at a fascinating study from the International Journal of Preventive Medicine on “calorie shifting.”
The Calorie Shifting Study
In 2012, researchers at the Shahid Beheshty University of Medical Sciences in Iran recruited 106 overweight and obese female participants aged 26-50 who wanted to lose weight[*].
To investigate the effects of calorie cycling, after excluding people who didn’t meet their criteria, they randomized 74 of the women into two separate fat loss groups: a calorie restriction (CR) group, and a calorie shifting diet (CSD) group.
For the rest of the study, everyone had their calories cut drastically compared to their usual diets — 55% fewer calories for the calorie restriction group, and 45% fewer calories for the calorie shifting group.
However, whereas the CR group had to eat the same amount of calories every day, the CSD group got to eat as much as they wanted for 3 days out of every 2 weeks.
Then, for the next 6 weeks, the scientists tracked everyone’s results on the diet. They also followed each group for another 4 weeks afterward, to see what happened post-diet.
Here’s what they found over the 10-week period:
- The CSD group was significantly less hungry and more satisfied after the first 4 weeks compared to the CR group.
- About 36% of CR participants discontinued the study during the first 6 weeks, while only about 15% of CSD individuals stopped before it was finished.
- Both groups lost weight throughout the 6-week period.
- The CSD group’s resting metabolic rate (RMR) was higher after their 3-day free eating periods compared to the CR group.
- Unlike the CSD group, the CR group’s metabolism continued to fall during the 6-week period.
- The CSD group lost nearly 2.5 times more fat (not just weight) compared to the CR group.
- After the 6-week period, the CSD group continued to lose weight, while the CR group regained some of their lost weight afterward.
To sum up, while there aren’t many studies on this style of diet, the calorie shifting study illustrates numerous potential advantages to varying how many calories you eat per day during fat loss.
The potential benefits of “metabolic confusion” include decreased hunger, increased fat loss, and an easier time maintaining results.
In the next section, we’ll cover some of the reasons calorie cycling may be more effective than ordinary calorie restriction for losing fat — as well as how to use it to add muscle without gaining fat.
1. Leptin and Weight Loss
Leptin is a hormone in your body that affects your metabolic rate, satiety (feelings of fullness), and fat-burning[*].
In healthy people, more leptin means a higher metabolism, more satiety, and increased fat-burning[*].
Additionally, it responds to food intake — less food means lower leptin, and more food increases leptin levels.
Research suggests that extra calories can boost your leptin levels, at least temporarily[*].
Essentially, while leptin probably isn’t the primary reason calorie cycling works, it may play a role.
2. Starvation Mode and Calorie- and Carb-Cycling
You may have heard “starvation mode” is a myth, but that’s incorrect.
And the drop in metabolism isn’t due to just a single hormone (such as leptin, for example), but instead occurs because of changes throughout your brain, central nervous system, and many different cells[*][*][*][*].
Researchers term this process adaptive thermogenesis, not “starvation mode,” but regardless of what you call it, it’s an obstacle for fat loss if your calories are too low.
Basically, calorie cycling might help prevent adaptive thermogenesis by signaling to your body that food is available.
3. Insulin Levels and Glycogen Storage
Insulin from meals can prevent you from burning fat for fuel — that’s one reason that fasted cardio is so effective for speeding up fat loss.
But remember how the calorie shifting study showed more fat loss with calorie cycling, implying the calorie shifting group preserved more lean muscle mass?
Because insulin is an anti-catabolic hormone that helps prevent muscle breakdown, temporarily raising your insulin levels with extra calories and carbs may help preserve muscle mass as you shed fat[*].
In other words, although insulin temporarily halts fat-burning, occasionally spiking insulin during fat loss may decrease the amount of muscle you lose, leading to better overall results.
And if you lift weights during fat loss (which you should), calorie- and carb-cycling could also enhance your exercise performance by increasing the levels of glycogen (sugar stored for fuel) in your muscles[*][*][*].
4. Feast and Famine Theory
Some research suggests that for humans, eating the same exact number of calories every day is unnatural.
According to evolutionary biology, our ancestors most likely experienced conditions of food abundance or periods of scarcity that may have led to a sort of natural “calorie cycling”[*].
In nature, can you imagine an ancient hunter-gatherer eating precisely the same amount of calories every day for months at a time? Probably not.
Additionally, regularly alternating between a caloric surplus and calorie deficit may be beneficial for your health[*].
In summary, consuming a calorie deficit some days using practices like fasting or calorie restriction, and a calorie surplus other days, could be ideal in an evolutionary sense[*].
5. Calorie Intake and Hormonal Effects
Along with leptin, plenty of other hormones also change in response to how much you eat.
Here are some of the most important hormones that change in response to your food and nutrient intake:
- Ghrelin and growth hormone[*]
- Thyroid hormone[*]
- Testosterone, luteinizing hormone, and other sex hormones[*]
Compared to a constant calorie deficit, calorie cycling may balance your hormones, which could enhance your results.
To learn more about how your body responds to calorie cycling during fat loss, read Refeed Day: 6 Benefits, The Science Behind It & How to Do It.
Want to design your own “metabolic confusion” diet plan, cycling carbs and calories to obtain better, faster results?
Here’s what you need to factor in, in order of importance:
- Your goal (fat loss, body recomposition, or muscle-building)
- Weekly and daily average calorie intake for your goal
- Actual daily calories (and how to vary them)
- Your macros and timing
Start by determining your goal. Calorie cycling works for fat loss or muscle-building.
Or, if you want to improve your body composition by building muscle and burning fat at the same time, without gaining or losing weight, that’s called body recomposition or “recomp.”
Daily Average and Total Weekly Calorie Intake
Next, calculate your average daily and total weekly calories using these formulas as a starting point:
- Fat loss: Body weight (lb) x 10
- Recomp: Body weight (lb) x 12
- Muscle-building: Body weight (lb) x 15
Use the appropriate formula to calculate your average daily calories, then multiply that number by 7 to obtain your total weekly calories. Write both numbers down.
For example, if you weigh 150 pounds and want to lose weight, your average daily calories are 1,500 kcal, and your weekly calorie count is 10,500 kcal.
Also, keep in mind that based on your future results, you may decide to tweak these formulas later on.
Actual Daily Calories
Here’s where things get slightly complicated, and the reason that calorie cycling isn’t the right approach for brand-new beginners.
The next step is to determine how many calories to eat each day based on your goal. Start with these suggestions:
- Fat loss: 5 deficit days, 2 surplus days per week
- Recomp: Every other day surplus and deficit
- Muscle-building: 4-5 surplus days, 2-3 deficit days per week
Deficit days are days where you eat less than your average daily calorie intake, and surplus days are the opposite.
For best results, eat at least 500 fewer calories than average on deficit days, and at least 500 extra calories on surplus days.
Overall, recomp is the easiest goal to calculate — multiply your body weight in pounds by 12, then eat 500 calories below that amount one day, followed by 500 calories over it the next day. Repeat indefinitely.
Or, in keeping with our fat loss example from above, that 150 lb individual would exceed her average daily calories of 1,500 kcal by at least 500 calories on surplus days (a total of 2,000 kcal), and would eat no more than 1,000 kcal on deficit days.
Lastly, double-check your total weekly calories and if necessary, adjust surplus day calories upwards or deficit days downwards to achieve the target total weekly calories for your goal.
Note that you can also vary the number of calories on each surplus or deficit day, but you should keep things simpler at first.
Macros, Timing, and Carb Cycling
If you’re new to calorie and carb cycling, simply eat whatever macros you usually eat every day — or you can use diets like keto, paleo, Zone, or another approach of your choice.
And initially, you should skip the carb cycling technique discussed in this section.
However, after a few weeks of calorie cycling, you can also try cycling macros based on the following activities to make your diet even more effective:
- Weight training
Here’s how that works: consume the majority of your carbs on days you lift weights, especially before weight training, and the fewest carbs on days you do cardio or fast.
Also, you can use fasting periods as an easy way to achieve a calorie deficit on low-calorie days, plus pair fasting with cardio for even better results.
Writing off “metabolic confusion” as bro-science might be easy, but that would be a mistake.
Calorie cycling, calorie shifting, and carb cycling are more accurate names for this dietary approach.
But regardless of what you choose to call it, there’s some credible evidence suggesting it works, plus the fact that plenty of high-level athletes and other successful individuals in the fitness world use it.
Whether your goal is fat loss, body recomposition, or hypertrophy, you can use calorie- and carb-cycling for more muscle, less fat, and better athletic performance.
However, beginners and people who aren’t dedicated to tracking calories and carbs will be better served by a more basic dietary approach.